Okay, I don't know how to make a poll and Vincent has a family emergency so here's the tot. Just pm me a ct by Sunday midnight NY time. You know the drill.
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Mon Sep 20, 2021 9:45 am
by Roshan
I found two more baby pictures. We have three SeFi and two FeNi. If you want to keep your vote like this post; otherwise write down the change. Then I'll post a couple of older child photos together early tomorrow morning and following that reveal and discuss.
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Mon Sep 20, 2021 6:25 pm
by -Sarah-
I’m changing my vote to FeNi (I accidentally liked the post, but I want to change my vote).
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Mon Sep 20, 2021 9:46 pm
by Roshan
Okay, here's a couple more childhood pictures. Like the post if you want to keep your vote or change it with a new post on the thread. Take one day so by 10 pm my time tomorrow night please.
With little sister:
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2021 7:08 am
by Amy
I’m changing my vote to FeNi.
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2021 7:56 am
by Roshan
Okay, everybody now has said FeNi EITHER before or after knowing that it's Freddie Mercury. And that's what I had settled on right before looking into him further for this and now I'm thinking he was ENTJ (probably dualized to an ISFP mother.). So do your research on him and let's talk about it.
I am kind of back pedaling on this so take the typing with a grain of salt. BUT my reasons for switching raise questions about what is ENFJ, if that's what the consensus turns out to be. Other common typings of him are ESFP and ISFP, which I have issues with for various reasons (and of course there is always ENFP which seems like a default stereotype for 'enthusiastic' public people). Anyway right now I have more questions than answers so I'm hoping other people will lay out their case, if they have one, for his ct.
(btw the video I posted is not one I had seen before).
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Wed Sep 22, 2021 2:44 pm
by Vincent
Okay so... i voted FeNi, quite confidently, from the first baby pictures.
In part because i saw a lot of pretty striking similarity with my FeNi daughter.
But the thing is.... i certainly wouldn't have voted FeNi if i had seen the older childhood photos first.
Especially the one with his sister.
From those pics, i think my first guess would have been SeFi or FiSe.
Now, i don't know yet...
I started looking into him and watched some materials but i don't have a case to present yet.
At this point, i'lm pretty sure it's not FiSe.
Ne polr seems very very very unlikely.
Also i'm pretty sure he isn't NeFi either.
Delta, Se role, Si seeking, Ni ignoring. None of that makes sense imo.
So far i find myself going back ad forth between beta and gamma, FeNi and TeNi.
I will have to watch more materials and to rewatch the interview to take notes and get timestamps.
In the meantime, i'm really curious to see what you guys think about it.
tbcd.
Re: Type the Tot #1
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2021 9:40 am
by Roshan
Well there isn't really much explanation here Vincent, but I understand you want to look at more materials first. Could you just explain now why you think you might have gone with SeFi for the older child photos?
Personally I'm kind of veering back to ENTJ, as much of an oddball typing as I know it sounds like, but as I've said in the group pm I want to hang back a while before I 'expound'. So I will just post an older childhood photo I didn't use before because it seemed way too recognizable. This is from British boarding school in India (his family were Parsis then living in Zanzibar).